Analysis
Defence spending is likely to get a boost this week – but it won’t be anywhere near enough
Rishi Sunak will deliver some tough remarks about the importance of defence spending and the need to stand up to Russia and China, but his own military looks set to remain as hollow as his words.
Deborah Haynes
Security and Defence Editor @haynesdeborah
Saturday 11 March 2023 02:00, UK
Aberdeen, Scotland, UK – 29th Jun, 2019 : Military personnel, veterans and cadets taking part in a parade along Union Street, Aberdeen, to mark Armed Forces day 2019 in the UK.
Why you can trust Sky News
Britain’s prime minister may not – according to some sources – be particularly interested in defence, but the defence community will be very focused on him this week.
Rishi Sunak is due to unveil an update of the UK’s defence and foreign policy on Monday – the same day as he meets with the US president and their Australian counterpart in the US to announce the details of a major new pact to build nuclear-powered submarines.
Two days later, the prime minister will be back in the UK, where Jeremy Hunt, his chancellor, will confirm as part of his budget a widely-anticipated but modest increase in defence spending – well short by several billion pounds of what military insiders believe is needed.
You can expect headlines about the threat posed, not just by Russia, but increasingly by China. There may well be a hardening of the language to describe Beijing in the “refresh” of the 2021 Integrated Review – the name of the updated defence, security and foreign policy document.
It had referred to China as a “systemic challenge” but this might be strengthened to be more in line with the tone used by the US and Australia.
However, the refresh is not expected to produce any fundamental shifts in strategy from the original review, drawn up under Boris Johnson.
The update was initiated last year by Liz Truss when she was prime minister and inherited by Mr Sunak, given the war in Ukraine and growing concern about China.
MORE ON BEN WALLACE
Defence Secretary Ben Wallace speaking to the media during a visit to Salisbury Plain in Wiltshire, where Australian Armed Forces are supporting the UK-led training of Ukrainian recruits. Picture date: Wednesday February 1, 2023.
UK ammo supplies have ‘borne brunt of defence cuts’, says Ben Wallace
Ben Wallace speaks with members of the media during a news conference with Baltic defence ministers and representatives from other NATO members in Tapa Army Base, Estonia
Defence budget has been ‘raided’ and there is an ‘uphill battle’ to get more, says Ben Wallace
Aberdeen, Scotland, UK – 29th Jun, 2019 : Military personnel, veterans and cadets taking part in a parade along Union Street, Aberdeen, to mark Armed Forces day 2019 in the UK.
Why spectre of British military becoming a ‘hollow force’ is now a reality
Related Topics:
Ben Wallace
Defence
Rishi Sunak
But the current prime minister has so far failed to commit to lifting defence spending above the NATO minimum of 2% of GDP in response to the increased security challenges, unlike his two predecessors.
Growing pressure on Sunak to commit more money to defence
Mr Johnson had even been planning to push NATO’s 29 other member countries to agree to increase the alliance’s defence spending target by half a percentage point given the need to deter Russian aggression.
Mr Sunak has been under growing pressure since the start of the year to pledge new money for Britain’s armed forces – in particular the army – as plans to fill gaps in their warfighting capabilities did not deliver fast enough to meet the threat.
This was exposed when Sky News revealed that a senior US general had warned Ben Wallace, the defence secretary, that the UK was no longer regarded as having a “tier-one” or top-level army, following decades of cost-saving cuts.
Is the British Army fit for purpose?3:13
Play Video – Is the British Army up to scratch?
Is the British Army up to scratch?
Initially, the Treasury was reluctant to free up more money for defence, given the huge demands on government finances from other areas that are more popular with voters such as health, welfare and education.
In addition, the Ministry of Defence’s dismal track record at delivering value for money with what is already one of the biggest defence budgets in the world means that Treasury civil servants are understandably wary about committing more expenditure, regardless of how persuasive the pleas from the top brass might be.
Yet, Mr Sunak and Mr Hunt – faced with the reality of the biggest war in Europe since 1945 and the lessons from Ukraine exposing the risk carried by Britain’s army, with insufficient stockpiles of weapons and ammunition – have decided to give something.
Money alone is not the answer
The prime minister is widely expected to confirm new money for defence during his trip to the US, where he will hold a three-way summit with Joe Biden and Australia’s Anthony Albanese in San Diego on Monday, while the chancellor will doubtless add his own words during the budget on Wednesday.
The increase will reportedly be £4bn-£5bn over the next two years – less than half the amount that Mr Wallace had apparently been calling for.
But money alone is not the answer.
Successive governments have tried and failed for decades to reform how the Ministry of Defence and its procurement arm – Defence, Equipment and Support – buy kit, from warships and satellites to boots and light bulbs.
Tom Cheshire2:16
Play Video – How much does UK spend on defence?
How much does UK spend on defence?
No one has so far managed a successful modernisation of this vital function, leaving the UK without the ability to arm its military at the speed of relevance.
This all means, despite what will doubtless be a volley of tough-sounding remarks by Mr Sunak about the need to stand up to Russia and China and the importance of investing in defence, his own military looks set to remain as hollow as his words.
Related Topics
Ben Wallace
Defence
Rishi Sunak
